Eid al-Fitr 2016

Determining the beginning of Eid al-Fitr caused confusion among the Muslim countries this year again. In Turkey it is celebrated on Tuesday 5th of July, although it will be on Wednesday 6th of July  in Saudi Arabia and some other countries.

The Presidency of Religious Affairs of the Republic of Turkey applies the correct regulations in the way that Qur’an shows. While Qur’an commands making observations about the times of prayer, It leaves the calculations about Lunar Calendar to groups of scientists. The Almighty Allah commands:


The sun and the moon follow a reckoning. (Rahman 55:5)

It is He Who made the sun to be a source of light and the moon to be a reflector of light, and He who measured out stages for it (the sunlight); that you might know the count of years and the calculation. Nowise did Allah create this but pointing out the truth and righteousness. Does He explain His Signs in detail, for a group of people who know. (Jonah 10:5)

Since there were no scientists to do the calculations during the lifetime of Prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.), he enjoined as follows being the only way out:

“We are an illiterate community; do not know to calculate or write. We know that a month takes either 29 or 30 days”

“Begin fastening when you see the Crescent (of Ramadan), begin the Eid when you see the Crescent (of Shawwal). If it is cloudy, complete the current month to thirty.”

Nowadays, there are enough of scientists to be able to compute the motion and reckoning of the moon and sun. The accurate principles were set at the International Crescent Conference held in 1978 led by The Presidency of Religious Affairs of the Republic of Turkey. Since then, the calendars based on the apparition of crescent have been prepared by the cooperative studies of astronomers and Islamic scholars.

The Shawwal Crescent, implying the start of Eid al-Fitr, is viewed with the naked eye. On 4th July, in the west of Chile, in Isla Santa Maria the Sun set at 18:08, and the Moon set at 18:37. Since the Moon was 6 degrees above the Sun, the Crescent (new moon) was visible to the naked eye.

Relevant technical information is as follows:
Isla Santa Maria

Latitude -22.4 degrees
Longitude 70.6 degrees west.
Sun 6 degrees below the horizon.

(Information obtained from Prof. Dr. Adnan ÖKTEN, Istanbul University Department of Astronomy Sciences)

Observing the crescent is not ordered in any of the verses. On the opposite, “determining via calculations made by a group of people who know”, is desired. In the ages when such groups were not found, our Prophet applied the only possible solution by counting on the naked eye observations. Carrying out this method at our century is neither understandable nor acceptable.

With best regards…

Prof. Dr. Abdulaziz Bayındır

İ.Ü. Faculty of Divinity Professor
Süleymaniye Foundation – Center of Research on Religion and Nature

Facebook'ta PaylaşTwitter'da Paylaş
Date: Jul 4, 2016
Other Fatwas In This Category:
#   Title Date Reads 
1 Kafir (pl:Kuffar) – Concealer 2009.09.07 1,743
2 Fidyah of the Ramadan Fast 2016.06.15 3,918
3 Does shopping on Ashura increase abundance? 2013.01.03 978
4 Getting the period while fasting 2013.08.05 4,562
5 Places of Worship 2013.12.14 1,216
6 The Traits That Make The Human, Human 2009.09.07 661
7 Iftidaa – Women’s Right to Divorce 2009.10.13 1,212
8 The responsibility of one who is not informed of the Message 2013.02.04 795
9 Compensation of unfulfilled fasting duties 2013.07.30 1,305
10 Combining of prayers 2014.01.01 1,976
11 The Situation Of Those Who Don’t Use Their Reason 2014.08.03 1,654
12 Marriage Testimony 2009.10.13 1,052
13 Are scholars successors of prophets? 2013.02.06 555
14 Zakat and Fidya in Ramadan 2013.07.29 2,020
15 Bid’ah 2014.01.08 1,215
16 Being Responsible For Your Thoughts 2014.01.17 1,453
17 Testimony Of Women 2009.10.13 1,502
18 What is the ruling of hudud law if we live in secular country? 2013.02.17 740
19 Fasting without major ablution (ghusl) 2013.07.29 4,045
20 Prayer of The Traveler 2014.01.08 2,153
21 Basmala 2015.10.11 1,274
22 The Saturday Prohibition 2009.09.07 5,828
23 Fasting Prolonged At Least Forty Minutes in Turkey 2010.08.20 1,895
24 Is terrorism part of Islam? 2013.02.17 1,421
25 Paying a fee instead of fasting? 2013.07.28 3,677
26 The purpose of iddah 2014.01.29 5,023
27 Christianity Today 2015.11.04 1,296
28 Baqara – Sacrificial Bull Issue 2010.11.04 1,494
29 Eid al-Fitr 2016 2016.07.04 1,415
30 Marriage without an authority (Wali) 2013.02.24 1,563
31 Are extremely hot and long days an excuse for not fasting? 2013.07.25 2,006
32 Mentioning God’s name while slaughtering animals 2014.03.07 1,446
33 Praise And Thanksgiving 2015.11.08 1,236
34 Relation Between Sleep and Death 2014.11.07 10,418
35 Period of zakat 2015.08.14 1,874
36 What about the missed worship before Islam? 2010.09.25 633
37 Fasting of women during menstruation periods 2017.04.25 4,696
38 Women in prayers 2014.03.16 2,677
39 Muslims Today 2015.11.03 1,801
40 Method to Understand Quran 2010.12.28 1,510
41 Did any fatwas come from Madhhab’s Imams about candle nights? 2012.02.06 472
42 Does Islam provide freedom of religion? 2013.03.04 796
43 Sects 2013.07.07 899
44 Intercession of prophets 2014.03.23 866
45 Introduction 2009.09.04 802
46 Kitabi Tahrif 2009.09.17 939
47 What is the ruling on taking drugs that include alcohol? 2011.09.11 554
48 Interest 2013.03.26 770
49 Should women cook for their husbands? 2013.07.01 15,733
50 Punishment For Apostasy In Islam 2014.05.17 1,819
51 Common Belief Mistakes – Preface 2010.09.06 839
52 Did The Jews Swear To Rebel? 2009.09.17 676
53 Do rich people have priority over poor people to get into the Garden 2013.01.21 551
54 Is Islam a religion of war, or peace? 2013.03.05 1,317
55 Does vomiting break the fast? 2013.06.22 8,517
56 Beginning of Ramadan -2017 2017.05.23 1,706
57 Religiousness in Quran 2009.09.07 1,001
58 Shortening of Ajal 2010.10.13 2,350
59 Is a convert responsible for the prayers he missed? 2013.05.25 631
60 What is the meaning of “people that your right hands possess”? 2013.04.15 4,617
61 The penalty of breaking a fast 2013.06.20 5,246
62 Touching and Reciting Qur’an Without Ablution or Ghusl 2016.03.30 10,330
63 Tesbih And Takdis 2009.09.07 1,408
64 Duty of the Intercessor 2010.09.25 777
65 Abrogation (Naskh) and Stoning Punishment (Rajm) 2011.10.30 2,130
66 Religion Difference in Marriage 2013.06.10 1,042
67 Dowry 2013.06.15 2,785
68 Nabi and Rasul According to The Qur’an and Traditional Islam 2014.12.14 4,828
69 Who Goes to Heaven 2009.09.07 2,198
70 Intercession 2009.09.17 1,082
71 Will Jesus Return to Earth? 2017.06.08 2,588
72 Wearing scarf while reciting Quran 2012.09.07 1,437
73 False Roots of Fatalism in Islam – Destiny and Measure 2013.08.03 2,100
74 Deifying The Prophets 2015.11.01 1,706
75 The Religions 2009.09.07 988
76 Questioning Sentences 2009.10.13 766
77 Spouses of Different Religions 2016.11.08 4,730
78 Women Travelling Alone 2013.08.26 3,356
79 Istikhara 2013.09.01 1,434
80 Is Five Times Prayer Mentioned in the Quran? 2016.06.13 4,812
81 Explanation of the verses 11-16 in surah al-Hajj 2009.09.07 3,732
82 Violence Against Women 2010.10.20 2,405
83 Is there a special form of worship to perform in the month of Muharram? 2017.09.22 1,380
84 Working of women 2017.07.05 4,273
85 Does Islam Focus on Men? 2013.11.23 535
86 CAPTIVITY, SLAVERY & CONCUBINAGE ACCORDING TO THE QUR’AN 2017.05.27 1,066
87 Munafiq – Hypocrite 2009.09.07 3,409
88 Friday Prayer – Salat of Juma 2009.10.13 1,539
89 What is the ruling on fasting the Ashura Day? 2017.09.24 2,643
90 Supervision in marriage 2013.08.07 907
91 Hadith 2013.12.08 1,083
92 Sealing of Hearts 2017.05.18 502