Is it allowed to pay fidyah instead of fasting in Ramadan?
Is it allowed to pay fidyah (compensation fee/ransom) instead of fasting in Ramadan?

The Almighty God has decreed:

“(The prescribed fast is for) a certain number of days. Whoever among you does not fast on those days because you are sick or on a journey, then (you should fast) the same number of days on other days. Those who are able to fast are also required to pay a fee (which is equivalent to the cost) of feeding a desperate person. Whoever volunteers to do more than good (which is paying more than bound to be paid), it is better for them. If only you knew how good it is for you to fast, you would (in spite of being sick or on journey).
 Ramadan is the month when the Quran had been sent down, that Criterion which is a guide for people and which also includes the explanatory verses of that guide. So, whoever among you witnesses that month must spend it by fasting. Whoever is sick or on a journey may fast for the same number of days on other days.” (Al-Baqarah 2:184-185)

According to the verses above, everyone, other than the sick or the traveler, is obliged to fast during the days of Ramadan in the way God has prescribed. Fasting is recommended even to those who are sick or on a journey. Therefore, paying no amount of fee can compensate for the fast that is not performed deliberately on the days of Ramadan.

Besides, paying fidya is NOT a responsibility that should be fulfilled by those who do not fast, but it is prescribed to those who DO fast in Ramadan. This expression is clear in the verse 184. For details of this matter and the common mistake about the translation of this verse, please see the following article:

http://www.islamandquran.org/fatwas/fidyah-for-the-fasting.html

 

Facebook'ta PaylaşTwitter'da Paylaş
Date: Apr 9, 2017
Other Fatwas In This Category:
#   Title Date Reads 
1 Are adjustments on amount of nisab possible? 2011.08.27 471
2 In zakat, are calculations of 14-karat gold and 22-karat gold different? 2012.07.30 2,559
3 Who must give fidyah in Ramadan? 2017.04.26 124
4 How do we calculate the zakat for variable amount of money? 2011.08.27 784
5 Are diamond jewelries subject to zakat? 2012.07.30 1,561
6 Should children give zakat? 2011.08.27 532
7 Should the widowed women and the sick give zakat? 2012.08.02 1,672
8 Period of zakat 2015.08.14 1,015
9 Is one year due when we give zakat from Ramadan to Ramadan? 2011.08.27 708
10 Can I give zakat to my aunt and cousins? 2012.08.05 2,571
11 What could be the reason for command of “infaq” -spending on others-? 2011.08.25 410
12 Can his uncle give zakat to my child? 2011.08.30 521
13 How do we calculate the zakat of our company? 2012.08.06 1,835
14 How do we calculate the zakah? 2011.08.25 881
15 Can we give zakat to our studying sisters or brothers? 2011.09.02 3,600
16 Are checks subject to Zakat? 2012.08.07 445
17 I am unemployed, do I give zakah for my fiancée’s bracelets? 2011.08.25 916
18 I am saving money for house; shall I give zakat? 2011.09.02 2,917
19 Are our cars taxable (subject to Zakat)? 2012.08.30 1,039
20 Who must give zakat? 2017.04.26 939
21 Can I give my zakat as furniture? 2011.09.03 754
22 Unpaid mahr in tax (zakat) calculation 2013.06.25 715
23 Do we have to give the zakat and sadaqat al-fitr in Ramadan? 2017.04.26 957
24 Can I give my zakat to imam-hatip schools? 2011.09.03 481
25 Calculating the cumulative tax (zakat) of 3 years 2013.08.04 645
26 I subtract my salary from my wealth to calculate zakah. Is it right? 2011.08.27 682
27 Does giving out food count as zakat? 2011.09.03 753
28 Calculating the tax (zakat) of lands and flats 2013.08.04 641
29 I am indebted for house, should I give zakat? 2017.04.27 1,082
30 Should a person without a house give zakat? 2011.09.03 724
31 Zakat from the money in participation bank 2013.07.29 461
32 Can we donate our receivables to debtors as Zakat? 2011.08.27 686
33 Can we give our zakat as food provisions? 2011.09.04 611
34 Zakat and Fidya in Ramadan 2013.07.29 1,451
35 Do we have to say “this is my Zakat” to the person we give? 2011.08.27 901
36 Can we give zakat or fitra to Turkish schools? 2011.09.04 566
37 Is it allowed to pay fidyah instead of fasting in Ramadan? 2017.04.09 241
38 Can we give Zakat to non-Muslims? 2011.08.27 1,416
39 Why cannot we give zakat to Turkish schools but imam-hatips? 2011.09.04 384
40 What is zakat? 2017.04.27 253
41 Do we give Zakat from shares? 2011.08.27 838
42 Can we give zakah money for iftari? 2012.07.24 1,975
43 Who are entitled to receive zakat? 2017.04.29 254
44 Can we give Zakat to the mentally disordered? 2011.08.27 490
45 Should we give the zakat of mehr? 2012.07.29 1,305
46 What are the commodities that are subject to zakah? 2017.04.27 283