Leadership of The Prophet
Prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h.) was a president, besides being The Messenger of Allah. Should we differentiate the rulings he set as a president, from the rulings he set as a prophet? Are the rulings he set as a president subject of shariah, too?

RasulAllah refers to Allah’s messenger. The messenger was informing people with the verses which he received through revelation from Allah. Prophet Muhammed was also presenting rulings about every matter from these verses. He was informing people about these rulings and putting them into practice. In Quran this practice is called ‘hikmah – wisdom’, which refers to correct ruling. It was his duty to teach and apply the wisdom. Allah the Almighty commands:

Just as We have sent to you a messenger from among you, reciting to you Our verses and purifying you and teaching you the Book and the Wisdom and teaching you that which you did not know. (Al-Baqarah/ The Cow 2:151)

Prophet Muhammad might have made mistakes while he was drawing correct rulings from Quran. Allah the Almighty warned him in case of mistakes such as the ones he had made in relationships with his wives (At-Tahreem/The Prohibition, 66: 1-6); with his practices related to slaves (Al-Anfal/ The Spoils Of War, 8:67-68); with allowing some hypocrites (At-Tawbah/ The Repentance, 9:43) and with his attitudes towards some Muslims (Abasa/ He Frowned, 80: 1-10). Therefore, by being corrected about his mistakes, he is proved to be a human being, not a god.

Quran is a divine book that consists of the verses that are brought to Muhammad through revelation. Wisdoms that our Prophet presented from Quran constitute his Sunnah. It shows that Allah the Almighty approves his practices by correcting his mistakes. Allah the Almighty commands:

It is not for a believing man or a believing woman, when Allah and His Messenger have decided a matter, that they should [thereafter] have any other choice about their affair. And whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has certainly strayed into clear error. (Al-Ahzaab/ The Allies 33:36)

But no, by your Lord, they will not believe until they make you, [O Muhammad], judge concerning that over which they dispute among themselves and then find in themselves no resentment from what you have judged and submit in willing submission. (An-Nisa/ The Women 4:65)

As a result, decisions and practices of the Messenger are binding for all Muslims, regardless of the matter.

Facebook'ta PaylaşTwitter'da Paylaş
Date: Jan 27, 2014
Other Fatwas In This Category:
#   Title Date Reads 
1 Euthanasia 2013.05.04 1,160
2 Abrogation (Naskh) and Stoning Punishment (Rajm) 2011.10.30 1,747
3 What is the ruling on dawah (preaching) in Islam? 2012.08.24 750
4 Is e-commerce legitimate? 2013.01.19 945
5 Hacking for good purposes 2013.09.04 1,149
6 Will it be a sin if we give rushwat for taking our own property which is wrongfully seized? 2013.01.27 599
7 Half siblings 2016.04.14 9,359
8 The expiation of an oath 2013.02.04 710
9 Prohibition of Non-Muslims from Mecca 2013.09.14 2,925
10 Should both hands of the thief be amputated? 2013.02.06 664
11 Abortion 2011.06.17 851
12 On what circumstances the hand of a thief should be cut off? 2013.02.06 847
13 Leadership of The Prophet 2014.01.27 753
14 Were the communities before us cutting off thieves’ hands? 2013.02.06 564
15 Muslim Attacks to Meccan Caravans 2014.05.04 1,262
16 What is the punishment of aiding or abetting a crime? 2013.02.06 776
17 Major Sins 2014.04.12 1,772
18 What is the ruling of hudud law if we live in secular country? 2013.02.17 564
19 Justifiable Homicide 2014.06.02 1,047
20 What is the punishment of a Muslim disgracing other Muslims? 2011.09.17 461
21 Punishment for Rape 2015.03.25 5,960
22 What is the penalty for downloading stuff illegally? 2013.02.26 787
23 What is sanity? 2015.10.03 1,093
24 Does not GOD clarify the meaning of “cutting hands” as injuring/marking in chapter Joseph? 2013.03.07 1,254
25 Can the rightful due be forgiven? 2013.03.19 1,135
26 Are actions that pave the way for unlawfulness forbidden? 2013.03.31 561