Can we do charity instead of sacrificing?
Can we do the charity instead of sacrificing?

The main idea of sacrifice is slaughtering specific animals at specific days for the sake of Allah. Therefore, the worship of sacrifice is not accepted to be fulfilled without performing this. The flesh of this slaughtered animal is eaten by its owner, relatives or acquaintances of the owner and the needy.

The Almighty God commands:

And to every community (ummah) We have appointed time and place of sacrifice[1], so that they might extol the name of God over whatever heads of cattle[2] He may have provided for them.” (al-Hajj 22:34)

Doing charity is another form of worship. However, different kinds of worships cannot stand for each other according to Islam.

 

[1] The word “mansak = مَنسَكًا” mentioned in the verse means “time of sacrifice”, “place of sacrifice”, and “the sacrifice itself”. In this verse, the meanings “time and place of sacrifice” are pertinent.

[2] The Arabic word translated as cattle is “an’am”. An’am is listed to be sheep, goat, camel and bovine of either sex in the verses al-An’am 6:143-144.

Facebook'ta PaylaşTwitter'da Paylaş
Date: Aug 31, 2017
Other Fatwas In This Category:
#   Title Date Reads 
1 Qualities of Sacrifice 2011.10.08 1,138
2 Sacrifice for Pilgrimage (Hajj) 2013.09.23 1,773
3 Can we sacrifice animals with deciduous (milk) teeth? 2011.10.10 952
4 Age of Sacrificial Animal 2013.09.28 778
5 Can we sacrifice a pregnant animal? 2011.10.10 2,312
6 Sacrifice Duty of Travelers 2013.10.02 453
7 Do we have to have spent money on the sacrificial? 2011.10.11 627
8 Female Sheep as Sacrifice 2013.10.03 1,071
9 Can we buy sacrifical animal by loaning? 2011.09.08 690
10 Meat of Sacrificials and Non-Muslims 2013.10.06 1,309
11 Does offering one sacrificial suffice for one family? 2011.09.10 1,620
12 Sacrifice with bank credit 2013.11.15 634
13 How much wealth should we own to be able to sacrifice? 2011.09.10 635
14 Mentioning God’s name while slaughtering animals 2014.03.07 1,356
15 Can we sacrifice on behalf of the deceased? 2011.10.15 1,094
16 Do we have to sacrifice upon buying a new car? 2011.10.05 1,079
17 Should I slaughter my sacrificial (qurban) myself? 2011.10.09 598
18 Do we have to eat meat that has been slaughtered by Muslims only? 2011.10.16 578
19 Is it permitted to sacrifice using a credit card? 2011.10.19 763
20 According to which calendar should we calculate the age of an animal? 2011.10.19 559
21 Is it permitted to sacrifice a horse, a deer or other halal game animals? 2011.10.19 2,640
22 Who Should Sacrifice as a Worship? 2017.08.30 984
23 Is it sufficient for two rich persons in one family to offer one sacrifice? 2011.10.19 791
24 Can we do charity instead of sacrificing? 2017.08.31 1,047
25 Buying Sacrificial by Kilos 2013.09.29 730