Places of Worship
Can one build a mosque and a church all in one? So on Fridays it could be used for Friday prayer while on Sundays it might be used for Sunday Mass. Is there any clear ruling about this?

Quran does not define a certain place to pray, but requires Muslims to make certain places mosques in order to meet the social needs. Legally, everywhere on earth is free for praying as long as the place is clean enough.

There is no problem for Muslims to pray in a church as long as its authorities permit it. But it wouldn’t be the way of the Messenger. Finding a mosque should be better, or converting a place to a mosque if there is a lack.

Naming a place as a mosque or a church is an issue about public administration. Muslims do not have to bother with the official status of the building they are praying in.

Now, let us consider the subject from the side of Christians.

If we are required by a group of Christians to pray in a mosque, we cannot prohibit them. But we have a right to ask them not to do their prayers by disturbing the regular prayers of Muslims. They can choose the free times in between. Historical resources indicate that the Prophet gave permission to a group of Christians from Najran to pray in the mosque of Madina.[1][2]

There are also some sects like Syriac Christianity who follow the authentic style of praying that involves bending and prostrating like Muslims. There is also no reason to prevent them from praying even in the same line with Muslims, if they ask so. We know from Quran that Muslims and Jews were praying in the same place together in Madina (facing Mizrah) until the verses that command the change of Qibla were revealed.[3]

[1] Muhammad Hamidullah, Prophet of Islam, Turkish edition, vol.I, p.619-620.

[2] Ibn Hisham, As-Sirah an-Nabawiyyah, Beirut, p.573-574.

[3] See: Quran, 2:143.

Facebook'ta PaylaşTwitter'da Paylaş
Date: Dec 14, 2013
Other Fatwas In This Category:
#   Title Date Reads 
1 Holiday prayers 2013.08.07 438
2 Istikhara 2013.09.01 915
3 Places of Worship 2013.12.14 834
4 Combining of prayers 2014.01.01 1,293
5 Prayer of The Traveler 2014.01.08 1,239
6 Praying with shoes on 2014.01.26 1,170
7 Women in prayers 2014.03.16 1,982
9 Compensation Prayer 2014.06.01 817
10 Can Hanafis perform prayers by following a Shafi’i imam? 2011.06.20 2,623
11 Religious liability of children 2014.10.29 640
12 Do scented materials harm fasting? 2011.08.16 886
13 Does laughing break both prayer and wudu? 2015.09.05 3,054
14 Cannot a person do prayers for 40 days after taking alcohol? 2011.11.01 5,548
15 Is Five Times Prayer Mentioned in the Quran? 2016.06.13 2,463
16 Going to Iftar invitations or Tarawih? 2011.10.16 952
17 Being in Awe in Prayer 2016.09.20 1,027
18 Time of Dawn (Fajr) Prayer 2012.01.03 1,648
19 Differences in Women’s Prayer 2017.04.10 118
20 Does serving alcohol forbid me from praying? 2012.02.21 615
21 Fajr time in Istanbul 2012.02.21 1,012
22 Is the holiday prayer an obligation? 2013.08.07 420