What is sanity?
What is sanity? What level of sanity is required to be liable in terms of Islam?

As a judicial term, the concept of a ‘sane person’ refers to an individual who is adequate regarding the mental abilities that serve to differentiate between good and evil, gain and loss.

When one’s ability to reason and differentiate is impeded, he or she is dismissed from religious responsibilities. The crucial point here is whether, at the time discretion is exercised, the individual has the ability to differentiate between good and evil. This is because while some mental illnesses permanently impair the ability to differentiate, others’ impairment of this ability is not permanent. The sufferer is responsible for his or her actions and exercises of discretion during the time he or she is sane. For example, epilepsy sufferers are sane in-between two epileptic seizures. Likewise, sleepwalkers have the ability to differentiate at other times.

SOURCE: Religious and Comprehensive Encyclopedia of Islam (Diyanet ve Samil Islam Ansiklopedisi), the entries entitled ‘reason’ (‘Akil’) and ‘mental illness’ (‘Akil Hastaligi’) by Hamdi Döndüren.

Facebook'ta PaylaşTwitter'da Paylaş
Date: Oct 3, 2015
Other Fatwas In This Category:
#   Title Date Reads 
1 Were the communities before us cutting off thieves’ hands? 2013.02.06 711
2 Muslim Attacks to Meccan Caravans 2014.05.04 1,614
3 What is the punishment of aiding or abetting a crime? 2013.02.06 998
4 Major Sins 2014.04.12 2,238
5 What is the ruling of hudud law if we live in secular country? 2013.02.17 713
6 Justifiable Homicide 2014.06.02 1,356
7 What is the punishment of a Muslim disgracing other Muslims? 2011.09.17 632
8 Punishment for Rape 2015.03.25 6,985
9 What is the penalty for downloading stuff illegally? 2013.02.26 920
10 What is sanity? 2015.10.03 1,389
11 Does not GOD clarify the meaning of “cutting hands” as injuring/marking in chapter Joseph? 2013.03.07 1,530
12 Can the rightful due be forgiven? 2013.03.19 1,428
13 Are actions that pave the way for unlawfulness forbidden? 2013.03.31 680
14 Euthanasia 2013.05.04 1,529
15 Abrogation (Naskh) and Stoning Punishment (Rajm) 2011.10.30 2,017
16 What is the ruling on dawah (preaching) in Islam? 2012.08.24 905
17 Is e-commerce legitimate? 2013.01.19 1,130
18 Hacking for good purposes 2013.09.04 1,416
19 Will it be a sin if we give rushwat for taking our own property which is wrongfully seized? 2013.01.27 727
20 Half siblings 2016.04.14 11,773
21 The Expiation for Breaking an Oath 2017.10.31 1,050
22 Prohibition of Non-Muslims from Mecca 2013.09.14 3,503
23 Should both hands of the thief be amputated? 2013.02.06 804
24 Abortion 2011.06.17 982
25 On what circumstances the hand of a thief should be cut off? 2013.02.06 1,025
26 Leadership of The Prophet 2014.01.27 1,044